If the Internal Revenue Service has started asking questions about returns you prepared for clients, you may be facing more than an audit. An investigation can pull years of returns filed under your preparer tax identification number, or PTIN, and interview the taxpayers who signed them. If the government reads the patterns it finds as fraud, a civil examination can become a criminal one.
A Georgia tax preparer fraud defense attorney can help you understand what the government is actually investigating before you answer questions or hand over your files. Griffin Durham Tanner & Clarkson LLC represents professionals under federal investigation and defends white collar criminal charges. If IRS Criminal Investigation has contacted you, or you have learned that returns you prepared are under review, call the Atlanta office at (404) 891-9150 or the Savannah office at (912) 867-9140.

Why preparers facing federal scrutiny call Griffin Durham Tanner & Clarkson
Over the course of your career, you’ve likely prepared hundreds – even thousands – of tax returns. When federal investigators review that work, they’re not necessarily just looking at one questionable deduction. Instead, they’re searching for patterns that they believe show that false information was entered on more than one return.
Since our founding in 2021, Griffin Durham Tanner & Clarkson LLC has represented business owners, professionals, and other people who are facing complex federal investigations and Georgia white collar crimes defense. Our attorneys include former federal prosecutors who understand how the government develops white collar cases. We understand how decisions that are made during an investigation can impact what happens later.
Our firm’s published results include persuading prosecutors to dismiss charges against a business owner accused of skimming proceeds and income tax violations after the defense challenged a search warrant. Our attorneys have also represented business owners and executives in criminal tax investigations involving the Department of Justice Tax Division and U.S. Attorney’s Offices.
What people say about working with our team
Clients and referring lawyers have described what our firm’s representation was worth to them when a career and liberty were at stake.
“The attorneys at Griffin Durham Tanner Clarkson are experienced, knowledgeable, and caring. They stayed in contact with me and kept me informed. I highly recommend these guys to handle legal issues that you might have.” —Jacques
“Griffin Durham Tanner and Clarkson are my top choice when a client needs high-stakes representation for white collar criminal charges, catastrophic injury, and business litigation across the State of Georgia.” —David
How we defend a tax preparer fraud investigation
A defense starts by establishing what actually produced the pattern the government found.
Suppose investigators identify dozens of returns claiming the same credit or carrying similar Schedule C expenses. That alone does not explain how those entries got there. The answers sit in what your clients told you, the documents they gave you, the follow-up questions you asked, and what you understood about eligibility when you prepared each return.
Due diligence records often carry the most weight. IRS rules require paid preparers to make reasonable inquiries when a client’s information looks incorrect or incomplete, and to complete Form 8867 for the earned income credit, the child tax credit and credit for other dependents, the American opportunity tax credit, and head of household filing status. The rules also require you to keep those records for three years.
A defense may require a review of:
- Returns and amended returns under investigation
- Client source documents and questionnaires
- Form 8867 records and supporting worksheets
- Notes documenting follow-up questions and client answers
- Client emails and text messages
- Tax preparation software and electronic records
- Billing and payment records
- PTIN and e-filing information
In a criminal case, what you knew and what you intended can decide the outcome, which is why the documentary record of how you worked matters as much as the returns themselves.
A tax preparer fraud attorney can deal with investigators and prosecutors directly and review the tax documents you are asked to produce before they go out. Where there is an opening, counsel can address the government’s theory before charges are filed. Tax allegations often arrive alongside other federal theories, and our firm’s white collar criminal defense practice covers those as well.
Learn more: Tax season tips to avoid fraud allegations
What is tax preparer fraud under federal law?
Tax preparer fraud is not a single federal offense. Depending on what the government alleges, a preparer can face criminal prosecution, civil penalties, an injunction against preparing returns, or some combination of those consequences.
The central criminal provision is 26 U.S.C. § 7206. Section 7206(2) makes it a felony to willfully aid or assist in preparing or presenting a return or other tax document that is fraudulent or false as to a material matter.
Section 7206(2) matters to preparers for one reason above all. It applies “whether or not such falsity or fraud is with the knowledge or consent of the person authorized or required to present such return.” The client’s signature does not resolve the preparer’s exposure, and neither does the client’s ignorance.
Allegations in these cases tend to involve fabricated businesses or expenses, inflated deductions, credits the client was not entitled to claim, concealed income, or other false information placed on a return. Other federal charges can travel with a preparer case, including conspiracy and false statements offenses.
An incorrect return is not automatically a false tax return in the criminal sense. A case under § 7206(2) requires willful conduct, so the questions that decide it are what the preparer knew and why a particular entry appeared on the return.
What are the penalties for tax fraud charges?
Exposure runs on more than one track, and the tracks are independent of each other.
Section 7206 sets the criminal penalty for an individual at imprisonment of up to three years and a fine of up to $100,000, plus the costs of prosecution. General federal sentencing law can raise the maximum fine above the figure in the tax code.
Civil penalties under 26 U.S.C. § 6694 apply separately, and they reach the understatement of a taxpayer’s tax liability by the preparer. An understatement based on an unreasonable position the preparer knew or reasonably should have known about carries a penalty of $1,000 or half the income derived from that return or claim, whichever is greater. Willful or reckless conduct carries $5,000 or 75 percent of that income, whichever is greater. Where both could apply to the same return, the willful penalty is reduced by any unreasonable-position penalty already paid.
A separate penalty applies to due diligence failures. For returns filed in 2026, the amount is $650 for each covered credit or filing status, so a single return can generate more than one.
Under 26 U.S.C. § 7407, the government can ask a federal court to stop specific conduct by a tax return preparer. If the preparer has continually or repeatedly engaged in that conduct, and a narrower order would not be enough to prevent it, the court can bar the person from acting as a tax return preparer at all. That second tier ends the practice, and the continually-or-repeatedly requirement is what stands between the two.
How the IRS builds a case against a tax preparer
It usually starts with the PTIN. Federal returns have to carry the preparer’s identifying number, which gives the IRS a way to gather every return associated with one preparer and compare them.
Examiners look across that population for credits, deductions, filing statuses, Schedule C businesses, or expenses that repeat. Clients get interviewed about what they told you and whether they reviewed the return before signing it.
Your own records matter as much, and the due diligence file is where examiners look first.
A due diligence examination is a civil matter. The IRS can assess preparer penalties for a failure to comply with the requirements, and it can also refer a preparer for criminal investigation. Once IRS Criminal Investigation is involved, federal law enforcement is looking at possible crimes, and the way you answer questions carries weight it would not carry in an ordinary examination.
What to do if IRS Criminal Investigation contacts you
If IRS-CI agents come to your office about returns you prepared, you do not have to explain yourself on the spot.
By the time agents contact you, they have usually read the returns and talked to clients. An attempt to clear up what looks like a misunderstanding gives them statements to measure against documents and other witnesses. You can decline an interview until you have spoken with counsel.
Preserve everything. Do not delete emails, alter notes, destroy client files, or create documents in anticipation of the investigation. Keep the returns, the source documents, the due diligence records, the communications, and the billing and electronic files tied to the work under examination.
Be careful about contacting the clients whose returns are involved. An innocent call to find out what someone told investigators can look like something else in a prosecutor’s hands.
Then speak with a tax fraud lawyer who handles federal investigations. Counsel can take over communication with the agents and find out what stage the investigation has reached.
Contact from IRS-CI tells you what kind of proceeding you are in. It should change how you handle every conversation from that point forward.
Learn more: Can you accidentally commit tax fraud?
Frequently asked questions about tax preparer fraud charges
Can I be charged if my client signed the return?
Yes. A client’s signature does not shield the preparer. Section 7206(2) reaches a preparer who willfully assists with a materially false or fraudulent tax document, whether or not the taxpayer knew about it or agreed to it.
What is the difference between an audit and a criminal investigation?
An audit or preparer examination is about compliance with tax law, and it can end in adjustments or civil penalties. IRS Criminal Investigation is the agency’s law enforcement arm, so contact from IRS-CI indicates the government is looking at possible federal crimes.
Can I keep preparing returns while this is pending?
An investigation by itself does not bar you from preparing returns. The government can seek an injunction under § 7407, and other restrictions can apply depending on the proceeding and your professional credentials. A tax fraud attorney can tell you whether any current order reaches your practice.
What happens during a preparer due diligence examination?
The IRS reviews whether you met the requirements for Form 8867, the knowledge standard, recordkeeping, and the computation of a covered credit or filing status. Your notes and your record of follow-up questions are what show the IRS what you did before the return was filed.
What if my client gave me false information?
False information from a client does not by itself establish that the preparer committed fraud. The government will still look at whether you had reason to question what you were given and whether the evidence supports willful conduct.
Can I face penalties without being criminally charged?
Yes. Civil preparer penalties and an injunction are both available to the government without a criminal charge. Criminal prosecution is one possible outcome among several.
Talk to our tax preparer fraud attorneys now
An IRS investigation can reach further than a few disputed tax returns. If preparing returns is your livelihood, a civil penalty or a criminal charge can take the practice and the reputation you spent years building.
If you have received a subpoena or learned that your clients are being interviewed, call the Atlanta office at (404) 891-9150 or the Savannah office at (912) 867-9140 to discuss your situation with a tax preparer fraud lawyer. You can also contact us online.